Blade vs Mallet Putters: Reflections on the Flatstick

Photo of author
Last Update:

Our website is supported by our readers. We may receive commissions when you click our links and make purchases. For more details see our disclaimers page.

Blade vs mallet putters, famous flatsticks, putting styles, and tour trendsโ€”Dan Camilli reflects on golfโ€™s most personal club and what the data says about putting performance.

Putting has long been called golfโ€™s โ€œgreat equalizer.โ€ Bobby Jones made โ€œCalamity Janeโ€ famous. Jack Nicklaus had โ€œWhite Fang.โ€ Tiger Woodsโ€™ legendary Scotty Cameron became known as the โ€œElder Wand,โ€ while Phil Mickelson has gamed the โ€œTiger Slayer.โ€

Itโ€™s also been called the โ€œMoney Club,โ€ โ€œScoring Stick,โ€ and โ€œTexas Wedge.โ€ For many golfers, putts account for roughly 40 percent of the strokes in a round. Whatever you call it, few clubs have a greater influence on the scorecard.

Ben Hogan's putter, USGA World Golf Hall of Fame
Ben Hogan’s putter, USGA World Golf Hall of Fame

Itโ€™s the putter.

The term โ€œputtโ€ comes from an old Scottish usage meaning โ€œto pushโ€ or โ€œshove.โ€ Its golf meaningโ€”striking the ball gently and carefullyโ€”dates to the 18th century.

Why the Putter Is Different From Every Other Club

Mallet putter being hit by Padraig Harrington
Padraig Harrington with his mallet putter

Unlike any other club in the bag, thereโ€™s no real replacement should your putter be uncooperative on any given day. Thereโ€™s no Plan B.

If your driver is not behaving, you can always tee off with a 3-, 5-, or even 7-wood. But what do you do if the putter misbehaves?

You lose.

How often have you heard a post-victory interview with a tour pro who said their putter was ice-cold all day, but they were happy with the win?

That would be never.

They do indeed โ€œputt for dough.โ€

In an era increasingly associated with โ€œbomb and gougeโ€ golfโ€”300-plus-yard drives followed by wedge approachesโ€”much of the professional game can still turn into a Sunday afternoon putting contest.

Thereโ€™s no club with which golfers have developed a more intimate, though often tumultuous, relationship. No club receives more affection and condemnation.

Even tour pros kiss their putters after makes and glare at them after misses.

When asked why he was using a new putter, Craig Stadler famously joked, โ€œBecause the last one didnโ€™t float too well.โ€

Putting: A Game Within the Game

blade vs mallet putters showing putter with Richard Green
Richard Green with his putter

Ben Hogan went so far as to declare that putting was an entirely different game from golf.

โ€œThere is no similarity between golf and putting,โ€ Hogan said. โ€œThey are two different games; one played in the air, and the other on the ground.โ€

Hogan viewed putting as an unpredictable game within a game, one in which great ball-strikers could still be defeated by adept putters.

The importance of the putter and the frequency with which we use it have led to all kinds of schools of thought surrounding individual models and putting techniques.

It has even produced what some might refer to as cults. Just look at the devoted Scotty Cameron and L.A.B. Golf communities across social media.

Arnold Palmer amassed an enormous collection of putters over his lifetime.

Then there are the โ€œglove off versus glove onโ€ schools, along with quiet-hands, wrist-driven, armlock, conventional, and long-putter methods of getting the ball into the hole.

Many of todayโ€™s tour pros putt without a glove and favor relatively quiet wrists, but golf history is filled with successful exceptions.

Thereโ€™s the enduring image of a gloved Jack Nicklaus putting his way to an unprecedented 18 major championships. Then thereโ€™s โ€œTwo Glovesโ€ Tommy Gainey, who keeps both gloves on while putting.

And, of course, there are the long-putter styles associated with players such as Bernhard Langer and Adam Scott.

Putting, one must conclude, may be the single most subjective aspect of the game. There seemingly are as many ways to putt as there are golfers.

Blade vs Mallet Putters: What Does the Data Say?

Which brings us to the blade vs mallet putter debate.

Blade putters such as the iconic PING Anser and Scotty Cameron Newport have long represented the traditional image of the accomplished golferโ€™s putter. Mallets, however, have become increasingly prominent at every level of the gameโ€”including the professional tours.

Recent data from MyGolfSpy and Shot Scope suggests that mallet putters can offer an advantage, particularly on shorter putts.

In Shot Scope data analyzed by MyGolfSpy, 15-handicap golfers using mallets made 82 percent of putts from six feet and in, compared with 75 percent for blade users. Mallet users also averaged fewer three-putts per roundโ€”2.3 compared with 2.6โ€”although blade users performed slightly better on long-putt proximity.

So the case for mallets is strong, particularly at shorter distances, but hardly absolute.

Why More Tour Pros Are Using Mallet Putters

Stewart Cink with his putter

We neednโ€™t rely on testing alone. We can also look at the golfers who putt to pay the bills on Sunday afternoons.

This is where we generally hear from those who love to repeat the old trope, โ€œItโ€™s not the arrow, itโ€™s the archer.โ€

Like most tropes, itโ€™s essentially a half-truth.

While it may sometimes be true that the problem is not the putter but the person holding it, thereโ€™s no denying the movement toward mallets at the highest levels of professional golf.

During the 2025 PGA TOUR season, 35 of 47 tournament winners used mallet-style putters. By late that season, all 10 of the top players in the Official World Golf Ranking were using mallets.

Perhaps the most famous recent example is Scottie Scheffler.

During the 2024 Genesis Invitational, Rory McIlroy publicly suggested that Scheffler try a mallet. Scheffler had experimented with mallets before, so Rory cannot claim full credit, but in Schefflerโ€™s very next start he put a TaylorMade Spider Tour X into play and won the Arnold Palmer Invitational.

McIlroy later joked, โ€œIโ€™m not going to give him any more advice.โ€

Probably wise.

Flagstick In or Out?

Like the blade vs mallet putters issue, whether to leave the flagstick in while putting has inspired its own competing schools of thought.

Putting guru Dave Pelz has long argued that golfers should leave the flagstick in, based on testing he conducted on how balls interact with the pin.

Research conducted by California Polytechnic State University professor Tom Mase reached a different conclusion, finding situations in which the flagstick can actually prevent a putt from droppingโ€”particularly when a breaking putt enters from the low side.

Pick your favorite authoritative source.

Putting has a way of doing that to us.

Why Putting Is So Personal

Thereโ€™s something mysteriously alluring, perhaps even archetypal, about the act of putting.

Something about pushing a little ball into a hole with a crooked stick.

This might explain the popularity of miniature golf even among those who do not actually play golf. My wife does not play golf but loves a round of โ€œPutt-Putt.โ€

Whatโ€™s the attraction?

Might it be the repeated ritual of creationโ€”bringing together yin, the female energy of the hole, with yang, the male energy of the ball, and thus making the whole (hole)?

A re-creation of creation itself?

Or perhaps it is simply because the closest many of us come to a Zen moment is while addressing a ball with a putter.

โ€œBe the ballโ€ is a humorous take on being unified in body, mind, and spiritโ€”a state golfers might simply describe as feeling โ€œconnected.โ€

The Best Putter Is the One You Trust

In a game full of rules, musts, and โ€œshoulds,โ€ putting remains the glaring exception.

Some golfers are loyal to one putter throughout their entire playing careers. Others change flatsticks as often as their socks.

How you approach putters and putting is entirely up to you.

Blade or mallet putter. Glove on or glove off. Flagstick in or flagstick out. Conventional grip, claw, cross-handed, arm-lock, or broomstick.

Each of us must ultimately find a putter that feels good in the hands, pleases the eye at address, andโ€”perhaps most importantlyโ€”instills confidence.

The proof is in the putting.


Photo of author

AUTHOR

Dan Camilli is a contributing writer for Senior Golf Source and a retired teacher and professor of history, philosophy, and humanities. He is the author of Tee Ceremony: A Cosmic Dufferโ€™s Companion to the Ancient Game of Golf (2015).

Visit Dan at DanCamilli.com.

Leave a Comment